Back on January 26, the readers here at Polipundit selected twenty questions they most wanted their Senators and Representatives to answer, and I began the task ofsending out communications to the 534 offices (special failing grade to Senator Richard Burr of North Carolina, for failing to have a serviceable e-mail address or fax number) available. As I have noted, most simply acknowledged the receipt of my fax/email, while others had an Auto-reply programmed into their email system, some of which were condescending and elitist.
Last night, however, I received the first specific response to the letter, from Congressman Paul Ryan (R- Wisconsin, D01). Here is Mr. Ryan’s response:
“Dear DJ:
Thank you for emailing me to request information about my policy positions.
I appreciate your taking the time to contact me with your inquiry.
I understand that you are interested in my feedback for Polipundit.com.
However, it is my policy to not complete policy surveys or questionnaires from any organization. As an office holder since 1999, I have strived to establish a clear voting record that reflects my position on policy matters.
By clicking on the following link: http://www.house.gov/ryan/issuepapers, you will be taken directly to the section of my web site where you can view issue papers of interest to you. Feel free to visit my web site anytime; the home page is located at http://www.house.gov/ryan.
Thank you again for contacting me with your request.
Sincerely,
Paul Ryan”
So, what to make of that reply? On the one hand, as some of our readers have noted, many Congressmen feel an obligation only to their constituents, and there is no reason to think that a Congressman owes a detailed answer to a publication. Then again, we have readers from Wisconsin here, so Mr. Ryan ought to consider their interest, and also as we have discussed, the fact that Congressmen are federal employees, known for accepting donations and airtime from anyone, with no boundary lines concerned when they are getting what they want, the responsibility to answer questions in a format and timetable designed for their optimal convenience is not unreasonable. I would say my first inclination is to give Mr. Ryan credit for the courtesy of his response, while following up on his suggestion to check his issue papers to see if he has specific positions on the questions we have raised. Mr. Ryan’s website has thirteen sections for his positions, so there is a lot of talk there. Let’s see how his answers play out.
Here are my questions, and the answer (if present) from Ryan’s website:
Q1. Should photo ID cards be required in order to vote?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q2. What will you do to secureour borders from illegal immigrants and/or terrorists?
A – No substantive answer to Terrorism, no answer at all to Immigration or Border Security
Q3. Is there a better solution to Middle East turmoil, than the establishment or promotion of freely elected democratic republics? Why or why not?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q4. What are your intentions regarding Tort Reform?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q5. If you could write an Amendment to the Constitution and know it would pass and be ratified, what would that Amendment be?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q6. What specific measures would you recommend to protect Social Security for coming generations?
A – Introduced HR 4851 “Social Security Personal Savings Guarantee and Prosperity Act”, specifically cites giving workers option to how their money may be applied towards their retirement.
Q7. Where do you stand on eliminating the income tax and SSI tax and replacing them with a national consumption tax?
A – Issue not addressed regarding Income Tax, supports continuing SSI withholding, but allowing workers control over where it goes.
Q8. What will you do to ensure the integrity of the voting system?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q9. What are the limits to judicial authority?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q10. Given that many states give equal treatment U.S. citizens, legal aliens and illegal aliens, just what does it mean to be a U.S. citizen (besides not being hassled by Immigration?)
A – Issue not addressed.
Q11. Should undocumented aliens have the ability to get legal drivers licenses?
A – [ UPDATED - Hat Tip Norm ] Ryan is co-sponsor of HR 418, which would deny illegal aliens drivers license.
Q12. What is your first proposal to balance the Federal Budget?
A – Ryan wants to “fix the process”, by cutting money from appropriations bills through amendments to those bills. He also wants to deny emergency supplemental spending, because Ryan believes “it allows supplemental bills to be loaded up with non-emergency spending, such as increased support payments to mohair wool and peanut farmers.” Ryan says “they should be decided during the normal appropriations process and not passed under the guise of emergency spending.”
Q13. What is your proposal for lowering the National Debt?
A – Ryan says “I am a strong supporter of paying down our national debt, but I also believe that the federal government needs to balance this priority with winning the War on Terrorism and encouraging growth in our economy. Based on Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates, including the unexpected costs of increasing national security and stabilizing our economy, the federal government is on track to reach government surpluses by 2012. I favor paying down as much debt as possible over the next ten years to prepare for the inevitable demographic change as the baby boom generation begins to retire.” Ryan believes that a strong economy is the cornerstone to this process, saying that “Government revenue is directly tied to the health of the U.S. economy”.
Q14. Confidence in the validity of elections has fallen sharply in some places. What would you recommend to repair and rebuild that confidence?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q15. What are the limits to the authority of the Federal Government?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q16. Do you believe the continued existence of a central bank (the Federal Reserve) that issues fiat money is in the best interests of the U.S.?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q17. What actions do you support for education reform?
A – Ryan wants more spending for Education, but not without care to insure that spending is used where results are the greatest. Generally, Ryan is an advocate of Bush’s “No Child Left Behind” initiative, but has not updated this section of his website in almost a year (the most recent reference date in this section is January 2004)
Q18. Should judicial nominees be guaranteed a “yes or no” vote in Committee? Why or why not?
A – Issue not addressed.
Q19. What should our short and long term strategies be in Iraq?
A – “Peace is the goal” . No substantive answer.
Q20. What should the United States’ relationship be with the United Nations?
A – Issue not addressed.
So, out of twenty questions, Ryan answered five, which gives him a score of 24% (5 for each answer, minus 1 point for the out-of-date reference on one screen of his site). For the purpose of this project, I am not scoring according to whether someone gives an answer I like, but whether a substantive answer is given. I will do the same for all the members of Congress. I would also be interested in your opinions of Congressman Ryan’s reply. For my personal opinion, I thank Congressman Ryan for responding, although I will wait to see how he responds to the inquiries from his constituents (assuming he gets contacted) before I give a final opinion on his attention to duty in this regard.
UPDATE: Norm pointed out Ryan’s co-sponsorship of a bill,which is added to his on-screen answers (though I wonder why Ryan doesn’t highlight the bills he sponsors on his site). Thanks Norm. - DJD
-- DJ Drummond